Home
Subscribe
Go to Our Forum – the heart of Catholica
Index of Emails
Pray-As-You-Go Daily Meditation
About Us
Contact Us
Donate to Catholica
Advertise With Us
Index of Advertisements
Forum Guidelines
Index of Lead Commentaries
Index of News Stories
Index of Editorials
Index of Multi-Media Commentaries
Catholica Video Channel


Index of all Contributors
Dawn Bowie
Francis Brown
John Chuchman
Fr Patrick Collins
Dr Paul Collins
Brian Coyne
Edgar Davie
Fr Daniel Donovan
Fr Tom Doyle
Fr Peter Dresser
Dr Ian Elmer
Dr Graham English
Vince Exley
Bill Farrelly
Dr Donald Fausel
Dr Brian Gleeson CP
Kerry Gonzales
Daniel Gullotta
Fr Eric Hodgens
Vynette Holliday
Dr Andrew Kania
Gabe Lomas
Dr Anthony Lowes
Milly/Amanda McKenna
Fr John McKinnon
Tom McMahon
Fr Kevin Murphy
Vinnie Nauheimer
Fr John O'Keefe
Dr Anthony Padovano
Dr Allan Patience
Peregrinus
Bishop Pat Power
George Ripon
Holy Irritant/Tony Robertson
Dr Christine Roussel
Emmy Silvius
Richard Sipe
Prof Len Swidler
Kate's TakeWendy's Take
Dr Dick Westley
Occasional Contributions
Lighter Material & Satire
Cindy the Sacristan
View from the Cloister
Ruth's Take
Farmer Jack & Pope Benny
Index to Special Series
Exit Stories
In-depth Interviews with Catholic Leaders
Dr Peter Tannock
Diarmuid O'Murchu
Bishop Kevin Manning
Michael Morwood
Catholica Conversations
Catholic Education
Tom Lee – First 500 Years
Cardinal Mehony – A Novel
Robert Blair Kaiser
Seven Deadlies
Special Editions
Spirituality of Thomas Merton
Sunday Reflections
Sunday Forum
Bishop Geoffrey Robinson
Youth Perspectives
Y-not Question the Sunday Readings
Catholica YouTube Channel
OnLine Catholics Archives
Catholics for Ministry
ABC Religion & Ethics Newsletter
Vote for a New Council
www.google.com


Catholica Web
Spiritual Marketplace
Uncommon Gratitude

GOOGLE ADVERTISING
Catholica does not necessarily endorse these advertisers. Please use appropriate caution and notify us of inappropriate ads.

DONATE NOW!

Spirituality for Adults

Email a friend Email this page to a friend

Print Print friendly view

Comment Post your feedback in our forum

Nill Farrelly
"The Trouble with Women" by Bill Farrelly

Bill Farrelly enters the lion's den with the headline he chose for today's article. Fear not, gentle souls, he has come to smite a certain type of man — funnily enough, the sort that are often seen parading around in dresses. Bill's trying to curry favour with the other half of humanity — and making a few hard-hitting points at the same time. It's doubtful though if the men in dresses might be capable of listening yet.

The Trouble with Women

by Bill Farrelly

I HAVE a problem with women.

My problem is this: Excluding the thousands of selfless nuns to whom millions are indebted, there aren't enough women in the places where you are often most needed. Who am I kidding? There aren't any of you in the place you are perhaps most essential — the altars of the Catholic Church.

Why won't the Church open its eyes to this ignorance, this arrogance? And please, don't give me the 'equal but different' argument. It doesn't wash.

But let's go back a bit. Why didn't Jesus set the example by having women among the apostles? If you're going to tell me that they had to look after the kids and the home, well, what about the blokes who dropped what they were doing and took up the Cause?

Sr Joan Chittister

Sr Joan Chittister

Besides, couldn't Jesus have chosen single women or women without children? So what if it would have challenged men's image of themselves? So what if it would have been a cultural oddity? Doubtless Jesus had a reason but I am sure he is not troubled by my asking these questions.

Have you ever read or listened to Sister Joan Chittister? Of all the beautiful women in my life, this Benedictine nun has had the most influence on awakening me to the priceless contribution women can make to this world if only they are given the opportunity.

Why are so many men frightened of powerful, knowledgeable women? And I used to be one of them. I preferred you to be only 'feminine' and alluring, soft and appealing — appealing, it occurs to me now, to my male vanity perhaps? Or, worse, my own insecurity. And in truth, allure and softness still hold strong attraction for me in the feminine.

Am I suggesting that an intelligent, powerful woman cannot also be a femme fatale? If I am, I'm wrong.

Another challenging notion — why was Jesus a man? Why does the the saviour of the world have to be a man? Once again, for those among you who fear I am bordering on sacriledge, I am confident God will not hold me to account for using the brain he gave me.

Sr Joan Chittister

Sr Joan's latest book "God's Tender Mercy" is available in the Catholica Spiritual Marketplace

Just so you know, I am not troubled by Jesus being a man and I would hazard a guess that almost every woman feels the same way. Part of the reason for this is that Jesus is also God and God is both male and female. To further confuse the matter, I also consider he is neither male nor female.

Joan Chittister is a feminist — but she is the kind of feminist every man can warm to. This is her definition of feminism:

Feminism is not about turning women into men or men into women. It is about turning both women and men into full human beings. Then, every institution in the world will change and both men and women will be whole.

You can see why I am attracted to Joan Chittister. She has written many books, including Scarred by Trouble, Transformed by Hope; Heart of Flesh and Called to Question. The first of these three is available also on CD. I have often found listening to these sages to be more enlightening and healing than simply reading their words. Sister Joan also writes a weekly column for the National Catholic Reporter called From Where I Stand.

Some bishops, I am sure, believe hell will freeze over before a woman is ever welcomed into the priesthood. I'd like to have a wager with them on that — though, sadly, I do not expect it to happen in my lifetime. What is most shameful about this philosophy is what it says, to me at least, about their attitude to one half of God's human creation.

I have stood proudly, if a little nervously — the cardinal was nearby — on the forecourt of St Mary's Cathedral in Sydney, holding a banner proclaiming support for the ordination of women.

It will happen, one day.

“Some bishops, I am sure, believe hell will freeze over before a woman is ever welcomed into the priesthood. I'd like to have a wager with them on that — though, sadly, I do not expect it to happen in my lifetime. What is most shameful about this philosophy is what it says, to me at least, about their attitude to one half of God's human creation.” ...Bill Farrelly

Bill Farrelly

Bill Farrelly is a retired Sydney Morning Herald journalist. He is a frequent contributor to Marist Messenger, New Zealand.

What are your thoughts on this commentary?
You can contribute to the discussion in our forum.

©2011Bill Farrelly

Share |

[Index of Commentaries by Bill Farrelly]

video.catholica.com.au
This Week's Featured Video

Creation Calls – are you listening? Music by Brian DoerksenCreation Calls – are you listening? Music by Brian Doerksen A video from the Farmers Branch Church of Christ & The Branch at Vista Ridge. Images from Sir David Attenborough's BBC series, Planet Earth, Music by Brian Doerksen exploring the beauty of Creation and the call to belief. Introduced by Tom McMahon to Catholica in his series exploring Human Sexuality. 6m23s [Originally published on Catholica on 02Mar2011] | [WATCH THE VIDEO]

Music 036: 02Mar11Music Index

Forum Index Page
Australian Catholic Religious Against Trafficking in Humans
Thank you for visiting Catholica

This site was developed and is maintained by
Vias Tuas Communications
www.viastuas.net.au
Click HERE to email the Webmaster