Home
Subscribe
Go to Our Forum – the heart of Catholica
Index of Emails
Pray-As-You-Go Daily Meditation
About Us
Contact Us
Donate to Catholica
Advertise With Us
Index of Advertisements
Forum Guidelines
Index of Lead Commentaries
Index of News Stories
Index of Editorials
Index of Multi-Media Commentaries
Catholica Video Channel


Index of all Contributors
Dawn Bowie
Francis Brown
John Chuchman
Fr Patrick Collins
Dr Paul Collins
Brian Coyne
Edgar Davie
Fr Daniel Donovan
Fr Tom Doyle
Fr Peter Dresser
Dr Ian Elmer
Dr Graham English
Vince Exley
Bill Farrelly
Dr Donald Fausel
Dr Brian Gleeson CP
Kerry Gonzales
Daniel Gullotta
Fr Eric Hodgens
Vynette Holliday
Dr Andrew Kania
Gabe Lomas
Dr Anthony Lowes
Milly/Amanda McKenna
Fr John McKinnon
Tom McMahon
Fr Kevin Murphy
Vinnie Nauheimer
Fr John O'Keefe
Dr Anthony Padovano
Dr Allan Patience
Peregrinus
Bishop Pat Power
George Ripon
Holy Irritant/Tony Robertson
Dr Christine Roussel
Emmy Silvius
Richard Sipe
Prof Len Swidler
Kate's TakeWendy's Take
Dr Dick Westley
Occasional Contributions
Lighter Material & Satire
Cindy the Sacristan
View from the Cloister
Ruth's Take
Farmer Jack & Pope Benny
Index to Special Series
Exit Stories
In-depth Interviews with Catholic Leaders
Dr Peter Tannock
Diarmuid O'Murchu
Bishop Kevin Manning
Michael Morwood
Catholica Conversations
Catholic Education
Tom Lee – First 500 Years
Cardinal Mehony – A Novel
Robert Blair Kaiser
Seven Deadlies
Special Editions
Spirituality of Thomas Merton
Sunday Reflections
Sunday Forum
Bishop Geoffrey Robinson
Youth Perspectives
Y-not Question the Sunday Readings
Catholica YouTube Channel
OnLine Catholics Archives
Catholics for Ministry
ABC Religion & Ethics Newsletter

www.google.com


Catholica Web
Spiritual Marketplace
The Battle for God

GOOGLE ADVERTISING
Catholica does not necessarily endorse these advertisers. Please use appropriate caution and notify us of inappropriate ads.

DONATE NOW!

Spirituality for Adults

Email a friend Email this page to a friend

Print Print friendly view

Comment Post your feedback in our forum

Tom McMahon
The systemic nature of the clerical abuse problem, Part 3

Tom McMahon has put in a long week preparing this commentary on the dark tunnel of clerical abuse. He's still got a focus on 1991 THE BOYS OF ST. VINCENT television documentary but in this commentary seeks to delve back into 19th Century history and some of the origins of the warped theology and spirituality that led to this crisis in the 20th and 21st Centuries. With the headline news from the Victorian Parliamentary Inquiry in the last 24 hours [LINK], it seems there are still huge lessons to be learned.

Series Navigation: Part 1 | Part 2 | Part 3 | Part 4 | Part 5 | Part 6 | Part 7 | Part 8 | Part 9

Meeting the main characters in the film...

Let's meet the fictional Brothers in the movie THE BOYS OF ST. VINCENT in one of Tom's priceless drawings.

The systemic nature of the clerical abuse problem, Part 2

A story goes with this art work. Tom moved from rural Sonoma and a public school in 2nd grade to Mission Dolores all boys Catholic grade school in the big city of San Francisco. The nun was probably 19 or 20 and she criticized my simple drawing. I was terrified and had a bowel movement that stayed with me all day. I never again drew in public until I made a Cursillo at age 45 as an ordained priest. Vatican Two has set me free to express myself. I am well aware that oppressive power is the backbone of Roman Catholicism. I cannot find fear, negativity, damnation, sin in the Gospel snippets we have of the historical Jesus.

Brief Explanation of the drawing: as Tom observed the Brothers in the THE BOYS OF ST. VINCENT. From left to right:

    The Boys of St Vincent

    There are a number of strings on the Catholica Forum where we have discussed this documentary. The link HERE is to one string which contains links to where the documentary can be obtained.

  • Most Brothers [left in the drawing above], stern, feet spread apart locked in a defensive position, threatening in numbers of 5-6 to a team that stands tall over the boys, hands hidden in a threatening way They are dressed in severe black robes with a belt carrying a cross. They never smile. Theirs would be a vengeful God with ordinary human beings born into a sinful state, punishment will drive evil out. I am reminded of Mel Gibson's faulty theology in THE PASSION OF THE CHRIST. This style of spirituality found its momentum in the days of the Crusades and promulgated by the hierarchy.
  • I call him Brother Hockey [center in the drawing above], his hands always external often touching gently as he plays with/coaches the boys. Craving his love, the boys crowd around him, face to face, gray haired and always smiling. Kevin calls him "Bro" a term of endearment and Kevin tests his humanity by asking if "Bro" goes to confession. Kevin has in mind his abuser and in his child-like innocence is searching for his abuser's humanity.
  • Brother Lavin [right in the drawing above], superintendent, always alone, severe face and searching/darting eyes. Behind his desk (a separation tool) he exudes power and secrecy. He is in his own paranoid world. Lavin uses Kevin to exhibit his distorted feminine side, fantasying himself to be Kevin's mother especially in his need to touch. A statue (Ecce Homo, suffering Jesus before Pilate) is on his desk. Lavin has a split personality (schizoid) and is paranoid (heavy upfront with a negative fearful view of life). He is a crusader against evil and buries his pathology so that he cannot/will not allow a conscientious intervention by the humanly genuine policeman. In the second part of the film, 15 years after the child molestation,s Lavin is married and the father of two children. We will deal with Lavin's pathology in a future commentary.

Forever 14...

Most of the young brothers are followers. This is evident in their drinking and eating. A mistaken understanding of obedience is to imitate the conduct of their alpha leader. Alcohol is a tip of the iceberg of sexual abuse. The boys, aware of this, steal altar wine and have a party of their own; permission is silently given for the boys to be future drug users and alcoholics as we will see in Part Two of the film. Although in their 20's, 30's or 40's most of the brothers are "forever 14" — sexually, genitally, and mentally underdeveloped due to lack of exposure to the outside world, especially. women. We will take this up in the following as we exam Irish cultural spirituality as introduced in the mid-1800's by Cardinal Paul Cullen. The Cullen takeover of the Irish Church will hopefully lead us to some understanding of the massive abuse problem. For unknown reasons Cullen's 1800's fearsome God did not take hold in this writer's 1930's training. Perhaps it was because my mother spoke more, with pride, of being an American than a Roman Catholic.

The Cultural Collision of the 19th Century...

The following is an investigation into the huge CRISIS COLLISION OF 19TH CENTURY THINKING AND CULTURES. Let me introduce the major players: Rice, Dickens, Cullen, Augustine and original sin, God, and the Little Ice Age.

WikipediaThe Little Ice Age was a period of cooling that occurred after the Medieval Warm Period. While it was not a true ice age, the term was introduced into the scientific literature by François E. Matthes in 1939. It may be conventionally defined as a period extending from the 16th to the 19th centuries, or about 1350 to about 1850 ... Little Ice Age Temperaturescrops failed and livestock could not be maintained through increasingly harsh winters. In North America, American Indians formed leagues in response to food shortages. In Portugal, snowstorms were much more frequent than today. Heavy snowfalls in the winters of 1665, 1744 and 1886 were reported.
[TMcM: Note the Irish Potato Famine is a sharing in The Little Ice Age. Perhaps this is why today we refer to such tragedies as "acts of God". Cullen will use these harsh weather conditions as smoke and mirrors to force out the communitarian aspect of the Irish culture. Love will be replaced by law.]

Wikipedia Source: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Ice_Age

WikipediaPaul Cullen: [TMcM: There is far too much important data for me to copy here from Wikipedia. I urge you to read the Wikipedia page. I select only a few snippets. Aloof Roman power over people is the core of Cullen' so called spirituality. Note in the following the politician Cullen is trained in Rome.]

Cullen is most notable today for being the first Irish Cardinal after 1,400 years of Christianity on the island. The improved condition of the Catholic Church in Ireland on his death in 1878, contrasted with what it was in 1850, afforded proof of the fruitfulness of Cullen's relentless zeal during his episcopate. Those twenty eight years marked a continuous period of ultramontane orthodoxy in matters connected with religion, discipline, government-funded education and charitable institutes.
While rector of The Irish College (1832-1850), Cullen was admitted to the intimate friendship of Gregory XVI and Pius IX. He profited by the influence which he thus enjoyed to safeguard the interests of the Irish Church and to counteract the intrigues of the UK diplomatic staff who at this period were lobbying the Vatican for support in European affairs. (W)
During the revolution that marked the demise of the Papal States and the beginning of the Roman Republic, he accepted the position of rector of the College of Propaganda while retaining charge of the Irish College. Soon after his appointment the Revolutionary Triumvurate issued orders that the College of Propaganda was to be dissolved and the buildings appropriated. The rector appealed to Lewis Cass, a United States politician, for the protection of the citizens of the United States who were students of the college. Within an hour, the American flag was floating over the Propaganda College. A decree was issued to the effect that the Propaganda should be retained.
Cardinal Paul CullenCullen also started the practice of Irish priests wearing Roman collars and being called "Father" (instead of "Mister") by their parishioners. [TMcM: At Trinity in Dublin I learned the Roman collar was the original sign of roman slavery.]
Cullen has been credited with the revival of Catholic devotion, e.g. Benediction, and rosary, in Ireland and what has been considered sexual repression. An extreme Ultramontanist, he vigorously opposed secret societies with revolutionary aims, as well as the system of mixed education then in force. His opposition was largely responsible for the failure of Gladstone's Irish Universities Bill in 1873, and he is held by some historians to have frustrated Cardinal John Henry Newman's plans for setting up a Catholic university along the lines proposed in Newman's The Idea of a University. [TMcM: Gentle Newman spoke of Cullen as out of touch with reality.]
In James Joyce's Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man, the protagonist's father mentions Cullen as one of the Catholic clergy who were very destructive to Ireland: "Mr Dedalus uttered a guffaw of coarse scorn. O, by God, he cried, I forgot little old Paul Cullen! Another apple of God's eye!"
[TMcM: This Ultramontane (beyond the mountains, aka Rome) Primate of Ireland preached that the simple Irish people are responsible for the famine and have brought upon themselves the wrath of God by their infidelity. They are a simple uneducated country folk as was this writer's great grandmother who fled Ireland to come to San Francisco in the 1860's. Cullen removes the clergy from the people, setting up seminaries so as to make proper English gentlemen of the priests. (Read Leon Uris's TRINITY and A.J. Cronin's KEYS OF THE KINGDOM, books that penetrate the Vatican smoke and mirrors.) Cullen supplants a gentle Jesus' community love with harsh theologies and petty devotions such as pleasing God by mortification and corporeal punishment for sinfulness. Cullen is the Mel Gibson of the 1800's.

Wikipedia Source: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Cullen_(cardinal)

WikipediaAugustine and Original Sin [a repeat from last week] One of the silent messages that underlies the conduct of the Christian Brothers who teach the boys in the film is Augustine's vile interpretation of the beautiful work of the Creator. Augustine, totally unaware of evolution as were the originators of the Garden of Eden myth, Augustine of Hippoproposes a fall (a downward collapse) from the original human nature given generously to all human kind by a loving Creator. [Genesis] Augustine, having lived abusively a wanton life of debauchery, immoral sex, child and wife/partner abandonment projects his own degradation onto all human beings. Michael Morwood in his books has done an excellent job of exposing this fraudulent theology. Fear of God and hatred of the body are the teachings Paul Cullen mandates on the Irish clergy and educational system.

Last week's commentary:
www.catholica.com.au/gc1/tm6/252_tm_121012.php

WikipediaCharles Dickens is a major feature of the February 2012 Smithsonian Magazine. "Going Mad for Charles Dickens" is the title. The article begins with British film director Mike Newell wading ankle deep in ooze and mud that is the replica of West London's Smithfield Market circa 1820, the quagmire a symbol of. the degradation and poverty of the day. Such is the arena in which Oliver Twist is born and survives.

Wikipedia[From Wikipedia] Oliver Twist, also known as The Parish Boy's Progress, is the second novel by English author Charles Dickens, published by Richard Bentley in 1838. The story is about an orphan, Oliver Twist, who endures a miserable existence in a workhouse and then is placed with an undertaker. He escapes and travels to London where he meets the The Artful DodgerArtful Dodger, leader of a gang of juvenile pickpockets. Oliver is led to the lair of their elderly criminal trainer Fagin, naively unaware of their unlawful activities. The book exposed the cruel treatment of many a waif-child in London, which increased international concern in what is sometimes known as "The Great London Waif Crisis" – the large number of orphans in London in the Dickens era.

TMcM: Furthermore I recall a saying concerning the French Revolution and the storming of the Bastille: "Repression is the only lasting philosophy. The dark deference of fear and slavery, my friend," observed the Marquis, "will keep the dogs obedient to the whip, as long as this roof," looking up to it, "shuts out the sky". Dickens wrote with an understanding of the Gospel conversions highlighted by Jesus. Dickens was a champion of the underdog, the poor, and the mistreated. With his father, once in debtors' prison, "Dickens made the wickedness, squalor, and corruption of London his own." He wrote about heartlessness and, rags to riches, seeing the world more vividly than others. Today's use of A CHRISTMAS CAROL may amuse many children while its centuries old message about greed and need still carries a powerful message.
Seeing them as God's children, Dickens does not condemn the poor but empowers them to revolt and demand justice. Dickens stands in sharp contrast to Cardinal Cullen. Their approach to life and people differ. I wonder what it would have been like in Newfoundland and for the Boys of St. Vincent if the works of Dickens were in seminary libraries and novitiates of the Brothers? Perhaps somewhere Bro Hockey got the Jesus' message?

Smithsonian Magazine Source:
www.smithsonianmag.com/arts-culture/Going-Mad-for-Charles-Dickens.html
See also related stories linked on that page.
Wikipedia Source: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oliver_Twist

WikipediaTMcM: Edmund Rice, a married man with the noble purpose of helping unfortunate boys founds the Christian Brothers, the first school, on Waterford's New Street, a converted stable in 1802, with a second school opening in Stephen Street soon after to cater for increasing enrolments. I see Cardinal Cullen strongly influencing the curriculum of Rice and his followers, they are careful to be obedient to the controlling power of Rome. Edmund Ignatius RiceBenedict, in the 4th Century, had mandated his monk followers to be obedient, that is to listen to one another, especially the youngest, so as to be well informed. Top down authoritarianism was not for the great founder of the monastic system. For centuries Rome has distorted obedience to be a mind controlling experience. Rice will teach Original Sin and his once innocent followers fall victim to a non-Gospel approach to children. Can one imagine the historical Jesus who bids the children to come to him abusing the little ones?

Somewhere and somehow some of the Christian Brothers, seduced into the want for power over another walked the dysfunctional Cullen path, forsaking the Jesus' model. The Crusades, the Black Death, Dante's Inferno, and corrupt ecclesiastical power, had taken a stranglehold on the Roman Catholic system of education.. John the 23rd's Pacem in Terris and the Vatican Two Council are the keys that unlock the stranglehold of medieval unchristian power. Vatican Two beckons us back to the Jesus and his loving Father. I encourage readers to meditate on the story of the Prodigal Son.

Wikipedia page on Bl Edmund Ignatius Rice:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edmund_Ignatius_Rice

GOD, under the Cullen system, will be forced on the children as judge and punisher. The present form of confession must go, especially for children. In 2012 Benedict XVI still uses the smoke and mirrors approach, keeping the God of Jesus (ABBA/Papa) out of human sight, camouflaging Jesus and his gentle Father by men wearing pompous robes and using exalted titles.

History has a way of softening reality. Dicken's A Christmas Carol is presently presented as children's pleasant reading when in reality Charles Dickens wrote to expose a terribly abusing power society. It continues to educate people today!

Continues next week...

Series Navigation: Part 1 | Part 2 | Part 3 | Part 4 | Part 5 | Part 6 | Part 7 | Part 8 | Part 9

Tom McMahon, San Jose, Ca. This wicked tunnel is hard to explore ... discouraging... 12Oct2012

“This Ultramontane Primate of Ireland preached that the simple Irish people are responsible for the famine and have brought upon themselves the wrath of God by their infidelity. ... Cullen removes the clergy from the people, setting up seminaries so as to make proper English gentlemen of the priests. Cullen supplants a gentle Jesus' community love with harsh theologies and petty devotions such as pleasing God by mortification and corporeal punishment for sinfulness. Cullen is the Mel Gibson of the 1800's.” ...Tom McMahon

Tom McMahonTom McMahon, ordained in 1954 and now married, lives a very fulfilled life in San Jose and continues to contribute voraciously to several Catholic discussion lists in the States. He has been an enthusiastic supporter and encourager of the Catholica initiative from the very beginning.

What are your thoughts on this commentary?
You can contribute to the discussion in our forum.

©2012Tom McMahon

Share |

[Index of Commentaries by Tom McMahon]

video.catholica.com.au
This Week's Featured Video

Michael Morwood: "The Challenge in Resurrecting Jesus in Society Today"Michael Morwood: "The Challenge in Resurrecting Jesus in Society Today" In this address given to WATAC (Women and the Australian Church) members on 26th March 2013, Michael Morwood outlines the challenges he sees the Church facing in the years ahead. This address was given in the theatrette of the NSW Parliament at a meeting to celebrate the 50th Anniversary of the Second Vatican Council. 33m 34s [Commentary on the Catholica where this address was published on 29Mar2013] | [WATCH THE VIDEO]

Reports 028: 29Mar2013Reports Index

Forum Index Page
Australian Catholic Religious Against Trafficking in Humans
Thank you for visiting Catholica

This site was developed and is maintained by
Vias Tuas Communications
www.viastuas.net.au
Click HERE to email the Webmaster