Does your community still say the Nicean Creed? (Main Forum)
In his recent commentaries Tom McMahon has written that "and Catholics every time they go to Sunday mass recite the Nicean Creed". I keep hearing reports that in many places because of the New Translation many have given up on the Nicean Creed and instead are saying the Apostles Creed. As a result of the feedback I've been getting I've softened what Tom has written. What is your experience?
To me there is a wider question: Is the essence of what Jesus Christ brought into the world a "Creed", or is it a "Way" of looking at, processing or navigating this journey we call "Life"?
Tom's Sunday mini-commentary discussing the Council of Nicaea in 325ce is online:
http://www.catholica.com.au/gc1/tm5/224_tms_290412.php
![]()
Brian Coyne
[Editor & Publisher]
Apostles Creed
Our parish has adopted the Apostles Creed as being the least worst of the 2 creeds. I don't say either of them and not just because of the sexist language. To me they are superflous in the liturgy, disturb the flow and are ridiculous. Bit like telling ourselves what goody little two shoes we are because we believe all those declarations when probably most people no longer do. People come to church for community and the body of Christ is present IN the gathering of people.
Sandra
Apostles Creed
I often wonder if we REALLY mean it when we say the apostles creed or just" rattle it off"parrot fashion !?!?

Apostles Creed
I could not agree more, Sandra. At our church the Nicean is recited, but I read something else while they are doing it. I have become quite good at screening out the burble of voices as I read.
Does your community still say the Nicean Creed?
We say the Apostles Creed in our Parish. This one annoys me because of its reference to Christ "descending into Hell". It always confused me when I was a child because I didn't see how it was that Christ could go to Hell. Of course I subsequently learned that the term should be Hades, the Abode of the Dead, not Hell, the place of eternal punishment. I wonder how many modern youngsters will get confused too?
I have been somewhere in recent times where the altered version of the Nicean Creed was said and I can only think it was while I was in Ireland back in February. I went twice to Sunday Mass there in a small country town (the church was the size and in the style of a young cathedral!). Very few people made any responses at all of either new or old version. There was no music, no procession in or out, no Offertory procession and on the first Sunday the only lay involvement was in the shape of two lay Ministers assisting in the distribution of Communion, hosts only, no wine. The following Sunday they did have a lay reader as well as the Special Ministers. All the lay people involved were women!
The Parish notices were read by the priest immediately after the Prayer of the Faithful which is a grave liturgical no-no.
I also attended Mass twice in a nursing home run by Camillian priests and brothers. They have a magnificent chapel there. Again there was a lay reader but the distribution of Communion was like the pre Vatican 11 days where the priest rushed up and back across a line of people, although we were standing not kneeling. There were no lay Special Ministers because there was a Camillian Brother assisting the priest. Again Communion was only under one species. I didn't get around to finding out if the laity have ever had both Bread and Wine at Communion as the normal thing at Mass.
Margaret T
Does your community still say the Nicean Creed?
Margaret, I haven't been to Mass in Ireland since 2005 but it was in the several palces I went exactly as you describe. No participation, mumbling, bad liturgy. Yet in the pub the night before the singing was to die for. I think the Irish might give up Catholicism faster than we did because their hearts are not in the church.
Does your community still say the Nicean Creed?
Brian, hi! Here recently occasional Apos Creed. Rarely question and answer which I prefer of the other two for I can choose to say yes if I wish.
Francis
![]()
My purpose is to remember the love that created me in God one with my brothers and sisters and with all life. My function is to extend that love and unity each moment to all.
Does your community still say the Nicean Creed?
The 1st time I went to Mass in Ireland in 96 - it was in Gaelic - it was over in 35 mins - included homily. My non Catholic husband waited in the car & was chatting to someone when I came out. He remarked - That was quick - the chap he had been talking to replied - There would have been a riot if it had been any longer!!!!!!
So much for the Irish been religous
Does your community still say the Nicean Creed?
my father, a builder, spent his time in Church in the 1930s examining the architecture of the ceiling etc.
Francis
![]()
My purpose is to remember the love that created me in God one with my brothers and sisters and with all life. My function is to extend that love and unity each moment to all.
Does your community still say the Nicean Creed?
Francis, your story about your father examining the ceiling reminds me that our church has an elaborate pressed metal ceiling which has circular motifs. I counted these almost every Sunday, as a child, and never got the same total two weeks in a row. Later I found out that a good many others did the same. So much for rapt attention to the Latin Masses. My father used to try to sit at the end of the seat alongside the wall so he could go to sleep during sermons and Mum had to keep her eye on him and get one of us to nudge him just before he snored.
![]()
J A Holznagel
Does your community still say the Nicean Creed?
I have previously posted the following creed, which I composed back in October 2011 when frustrated with the new liturgy translations about to be forced upon the English speaking church.
For many years and to this very day, I have trouble with both the Apostle's Creed and the Nicean Creed. They are antiquated and filled with ideas that are most difficult to accept today.
The creed below reflects many ideas drawn from many resources, which I have attempted to put into my own words. When writing these ideas, they just flowed easily and joyously from my heart in prayer.
Our “Catholic” Creed for Today’s World
We believe in one God,
our loving parent,
Creator of the whole universe,
and all life known to us,
both seen, unseen and still to be discovered.
We believe that we are but a very small part of
God’s vast creation; which began billions of years ago;
yet knowing we are loved intimately by our God.
God permeates through out the entire Cosmos
and is within us, never leaving us.
We believe in Jesus,
our brother and our teacher,
who was born into this world like us,
loved by human parents.
Jesus showed us how we are passionately loved by God,
from the very beginning;
for humanity was never separated from God.
Jesus taught us that all life is in relationship,
with God, with nature and all humanity.
Jesus brought us out of our human darkness,
to show us the way of living as true children of God.
To embrace our humanity; that to error is human;
and to live our lives to the fullest,
which is God’s vision for all humanity.
Jesus lived to make known to us God’s vision of
compassion and justice in our world.
How we are capable to shape the future
by his Companionship of Empowerment,
which we have always known as Gods’ reign.
For Jesus’ challenging and revolutionary ideas,
he was murdered on a Roman cross;
executed as a common criminal,
by those in religious and civil power,
who were threatened by what Jesus taught
to liberate us from their bonds of control and domination.
Jesus gave his life for what he passionately believed.
Through death God raised Jesus to new life,
to show us the next step in our human evolution.
God showed us what is gifted to us after
our earthly human lives have concluded.
We understand that God’s creation
is a process of birth, death and rebirth.
All creation is embraced in this mystery
from the first moment creation began.
We are continually challenged by God’s Spirit
to seek Truth; to question our beliefs,
and Church teachings for new insights;
and not rely solely on past myths
so that we achieve maturity in our living faith.
Jesus’ Spirit, God’s breathe of love,
lives deeply on through his followers who
commemorate what Jesus said to do in his memory
by our Eucharistic celebration.
Through the Eucharist we are nourished and
empowered to change the world around us,
to preserve the gift of our home we call Earth,
for the good of all humanity,
and bring Gods’ reign into reality today.
Amen, so be it.
Does your community still say the Nicean Creed?
No - we don't say the creed at mass.
Instead we sing the creed shown below.
This in a significant well-heeled and well-attended Catholic parish in good standing.
I won't be saying where but there is at least one other person on this board who goes there.
Holy God, we praise thy name;
Lord of all, we bow before thee.
All on earth thy sceptre claim,
All in heaven above adore thee.
Infinite thy vast domain,
Everlasting is thy reign.
Holy Father, holy Son,
Holy Spirit, three we name thee,
Though in essence only one;
Undivided God we 'claim thee
And, adoring, bend the knee
While we own the mystery.
Hymn # 171 from Lutheran Worship
Author: Maria Theresa
Tune: Grosser Gott
1st Published in: 1774
AMEN
George Haydock.
(I also hear that in the local cathedral, the congregation at one mass that previously actively participated in the liturgy through their responses now stand mute when greeted with, "The Lord be with you." So resistance is happening. I am happy to respond, "And also with you". And I do - I found it hard at first but now find it freeing and find that it helps me to focus.)
Does your community still say the Nicean Creed?
We samg that too thru the 50s & 60s
Does your community still say the Nicean Creed?
I could guess where. And that was long before the "new"\liturgy. Everybody seemed happy with it, and I don't think any comlaint has gone to +Levada.
Does your community still say the Nicean Creed?
What a joy to read your responses . I read/see a happy free people. Journeyman I have copied your creed....wondabar! and Geo H I see the value of our Holy God we praise thy name etc. I do enjoy your muteness. Tom in America
![]()
Tom in San Jose
Does your community still say the Nicean Creed?
Tom,
Thank you for your compliment. I am filled with joy!
Does your community still say the Nicean Creed?
Take2
I do not believe that creeds are necessary. They encourage fundamentalism and create a barrier for unity
among the Christian Denominations, - better to recite what we should be doing.
The creeds were written in earlier centuries by men (and for men) and they have no part in today's mass.
Since the new liturgy has been introduced in this district i take along John Chuchman's book "I Am because Love Is" God as Verb. and read that when the creed is being recited.
And make my own responses - in a loud voice.
MaryNym
















