Question without notice (Main Forum)
My question is - the Church is still with us, why is this so? Is it really because the Church is divinely ruled? Even though the Popes have been collective bastards, the Church somehow lurches from one century to the an other more or less intact.
Now, of course this could be simply because up until the 20th century, the majority of 'simple people' were not educated enough to be able to argue back and so they stuck to the Church because at least it kept the community together, gave the people identity and before universal medical care, offered hope to those who were in need of care.
But now, with universal education and governments taking on the social welfare role that once the Church took on, people don't 'need' the Church in that way any more and that is why there more action taken to walk away from the dictatorship of the hierachy.
Will the Church survive in its present form now? Though it has in the past - we are not threatened any more with hell and damnation.
Helen
![]()
Let us light a candle and say to the dark, we beg to differ
Complete thread:
- Trying to better understand the Catholic Church's current woes... - Brian Coyne, 2012-05-22, 10:07
![Open whole thread [*]](templates/Catholica1/images/complete_thread.png)
- Trying to better understand the Catholic Church's current woes... - PeterR, 2012-05-22, 15:24
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Trying to better understand the Catholic Church's current woes... - Gaile M. Pohlhaus, 2012-05-23, 06:15
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Trying to better understand the Catholic Church's current woes... - AsOne, 2012-05-23, 13:07
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Trying to better understand the Catholic Church's current woes... - AsOne, 2012-05-23, 13:07
- Trying to better understand the Catholic Church's current woes... - Gaile M. Pohlhaus, 2012-05-23, 06:15
- Stories never taught in Catholic school: Part 2 is now online.... - Brian Coyne, 2012-05-23, 12:46
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- We should have been warned what to expect ... - PeterR, 2012-05-23, 15:28
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- We should have been warned what to expect ... - Brian Coyne, 2012-05-23, 15:52
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Question without notice - Helen, 2012-05-23, 16:23
- Question without notice - Vince, 2012-05-23, 16:44
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Question without notice - Sue, 2012-05-23, 17:00
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Question without notice - James, 2012-05-23, 17:48
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Question without notice - James, 2012-05-23, 17:48
- Question without notice - Helen, 2012-05-23, 18:01
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Question without notice - georgeh, 2012-05-23, 22:50
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Question without notice - georgeh, 2012-05-23, 22:50
- Question without notice - Sue, 2012-05-23, 17:00
- Question without notice - Vince, 2012-05-23, 16:44
- We should have been warned what to expect ... - Francis, 2012-05-23, 17:42
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Two perspectives... - Brian Coyne, 2012-05-23, 20:33
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Two perspectives... - Francis, 2012-05-23, 21:14
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Two perspectives... - judith, 2012-05-23, 23:22
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Two perspectives... - judith, 2012-05-23, 23:22
- Taking it all seriously... - Brian Coyne, 2012-05-23, 21:18
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Taking it all seriously... - Francis, 2012-05-23, 21:47
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Taking it all seriously... - Enda, 2012-05-23, 22:26
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Taking it all seriously... - Francis, 2012-05-23, 22:32
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Taking it all seriously... - Francis, 2012-05-23, 22:32
- Taking it all seriously... - James, 2012-05-24, 03:34
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Taking it all seriously... - georgeh, 2012-05-24, 08:12
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Taking it all seriously... - georgeh, 2012-05-24, 08:12
- Taking it all seriously... - Francis, 2012-05-23, 21:47
- Two perspectives...and, a few more - Journeyman, 2012-05-24, 02:54
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- It's the gzillion dollar question... - Brian Coyne, 2012-05-24, 14:09
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- It's the gzillion dollar question... - Francis, 2012-05-24, 15:49
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- You don't need to go to Church to meet them, Francis... - Brian Coyne, 2012-05-24, 16:23
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- You don't need to go to Church to meet them, Francis... - Brian Coyne, 2012-05-24, 16:23
- It's the gzillion dollar question... - Francis, 2012-05-24, 15:49
- Is there anything attractive about today's Church? - Sue, 2012-05-24, 14:44
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Is there anything attractive about today's Church? - judith, 2012-05-24, 16:42
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Is there anything attractive about today's Church? - Sue, 2012-05-24, 19:39
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Is there anything attractive about today's Church? - Francis, 2012-05-24, 20:31
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Is there anything attractive about today's Church? - Ynot, 2012-05-24, 22:51
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Is there anything attractive about today's Church? - Ynot, 2012-05-24, 22:51
- Is there anything attractive about today's Church? - judith, 2012-05-24, 20:39
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Is there anything attractive about today's Church? - georgeh, 2012-05-24, 23:19
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Is there anything attractive about today's Church? - Francis, 2012-05-24, 20:31
- Is there anything attractive about today's Church? - curlie que, 2012-05-25, 20:01
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Is there anything attractive about today's Church? - Sue, 2012-05-24, 19:39
- Is there anything attractive about today's Church? - judith, 2012-05-24, 16:42
- Two perspectives...and, a few more - Helen, 2012-05-24, 15:03
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Two perspectives...and, a few more - Marian, 2012-05-24, 18:28
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- It's the gzillion dollar question... - Brian Coyne, 2012-05-24, 14:09
- Two perspectives...walk or stay - Liz, 2012-05-24, 06:09
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Two perspectives...walk or stay - James, 2012-05-24, 07:10
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Two perspectives...walk or stay - Liz, 2012-05-24, 08:19
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Two perspectives...Yay or Nay? - desi, 2012-05-24, 11:42
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Two perspectives...Yay or Nay? - Helen, 2012-05-24, 11:43
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- The Third Way : Becoming Cafeteria - James, 2012-05-24, 14:58
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- One possibility that intrigues me: another French or American Revolution? - Brian Coyne, 2012-05-24, 16:04
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- One possibility that intrigues me: another French or American Revolution? - James, 2012-05-24, 16:17
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- One possibility that intrigues me: another French or American Revolution? - James, 2012-05-24, 16:17
- One possibility that intrigues me: another French or American Revolution? - Brian Coyne, 2012-05-24, 16:04
- Good one, desi! - CathyT, 2012-05-24, 17:02
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Good one, desi! - gemstones, 2012-05-24, 19:13
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Good one, desi! - gemstones, 2012-05-24, 19:13
- Two perspectives...Yay or Nay? - Helen, 2012-05-24, 11:43
- Two perspectives...Yay or Nay? - desi, 2012-05-24, 11:42
- Two perspectives...walk or stay - Liz, 2012-05-24, 08:19
- Two perspectives...walk or stay - James, 2012-05-24, 07:10
- Two perspectives... - Vince, 2012-05-24, 16:43
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- The problem of evil and suffering... - Brian Coyne, 2012-05-24, 17:15
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- The problem of evil and suffering... - Francis, 2012-05-24, 18:19
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- The problem of evil and suffering... - Francis, 2012-05-24, 18:19
- The problem of evil and suffering... - Brian Coyne, 2012-05-24, 17:15
- Two perspectives... - Francis, 2012-05-23, 21:14
- Two perspectives... - Brian Coyne, 2012-05-23, 20:33
- Question without notice - Helen, 2012-05-23, 16:23
- We should have been warned what to expect ... - Brian Coyne, 2012-05-23, 15:52
- We should have been warned what to expect ... - PeterR, 2012-05-23, 15:28
- The Conclusion to Fr Dan Donovan's analysis is now online... - Brian Coyne, 2012-05-24, 13:24
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Yes it is! n/t - Ynot, 2012-05-24, 13:27
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- LOL, Tony. - Brian Coyne, 2012-05-24, 13:34
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Thank you to everyone who has contributed to this conversation - Bill Dowsley, 2012-05-24, 14:17
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Thank you to everyone who has contributed to this conversation - Bill Dowsley, 2012-05-24, 14:17
- LOL, Tony. - Brian Coyne, 2012-05-24, 13:34
- The Conclusion to Fr Dan Donovan's analysis is now online... - Helen, 2012-05-24, 15:10
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- The role of the local bishop is...... - desi, 2012-05-24, 15:24
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- The role of the local bishop is...... - desi, 2012-05-24, 15:30
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- The role of the local bishop is to listen to the people - Enda, 2012-05-24, 16:25
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- The role of the local bishop is...... - desi, 2012-05-24, 16:29
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- The role of the local bishop is...... - curlie que, 2012-05-24, 16:29
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- The role of the local bishop is...... - Helen, 2012-05-24, 17:55
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- The role of the local bishop is to listen to the people - Enda, 2012-05-24, 16:25
- The role of the local bishop is...... - judith, 2012-05-24, 16:17
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- SPEAKING OF CARDINAL KOCH - kaythegardener, 2012-05-25, 08:46
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- SPEAKING OF CARDINAL KOCH - kaythegardener, 2012-05-25, 08:46
- The role of the local bishop is...... - desi, 2012-05-24, 15:30
- The role of the local bishop is...... - desi, 2012-05-24, 15:24
- Yes it is! n/t - Ynot, 2012-05-24, 13:27
- Trying to better understand the Catholic Church's current woes... - PeterR, 2012-05-22, 15:24
















