Do we need a Papacy or a "central head office"? (Main Forum)
Within the other religions and traditions though, Sue, I sense there is growing consensus for a need for some coordinating body. Over the last century or so we have seen the gradual rise of initiatives like the National Council of Churches, the World Parliament of Religions, the World Council of Churches, which in different ways would seem to be testimony to this human desire for either some "symbol of unity" or a place where consensus can be argued and achieved or a place from which a religious consensus position can be argued in other realms in society (such as national parliaments or the UN). More likely it's a combination of all those things. To me the crucial element is the beliefs and attitudes of those who are elected, or chosen, to work in such a central authority.
![]()
Brian Coyne
[Editor & Publisher]
Complete thread:
- "Should we stay or leave?"... - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-16, 13:56
![Open whole thread [*]](templates/Catholica1/images/complete_thread.png)
- I'm "stayin' put"... - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-16, 18:14
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- I'm "stayin' put"... - judith, 2012-04-16, 19:26
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- I'm "stayin' put"... - curlie que, 2012-04-16, 20:30
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- I'm "stayin' put"... - curlie que, 2012-04-16, 20:30
- I'm "stayin' put"... - judith, 2012-04-16, 19:26
- NOW ONLINE: "Should we stay or leave?"... - Nicholas, 2012-04-16, 21:41
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- NOW ONLINE: "Should we stay or leave?"... - Chris Hum, 2012-04-16, 22:26
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- NOW ONLINE: "Should we stay or leave?"... - curlie que, 2012-04-16, 22:56
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- NOW ONLINE: "Should we stay or leave?"... - kaythegardener, 2012-04-16, 23:02
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- NOW ONLINE: "Should we stay or leave?"... - Nicholas, 2012-04-16, 23:07
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- A tougher question... - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-17, 00:01
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Jesus' message is tough - Debb, 2012-04-17, 11:31
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Jesus' message is tough - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-17, 12:07
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Jesus' message is tough - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-17, 12:07
- A tougher question: what does Jesus offer humanity? - Chris Hum, 2012-04-17, 13:01
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- A tougher question: what does Jesus offer humanity? - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-17, 21:37
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- A tougher question: what does Jesus offer humanity? - Chris Hum, 2012-04-18, 13:22
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- A tougher question: what does Jesus offer humanity? - Chris Hum, 2012-04-18, 13:22
- A tougher question: what does Jesus offer humanity? - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-17, 21:37
- Jesus' message is tough - Debb, 2012-04-17, 11:31
- NOW ONLINE: "Should we stay or leave?"... - curlie que, 2012-04-16, 22:56
- NOW ONLINE: "Should we stay or leave?"... - georgeh, 2012-04-17, 14:13
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- NOW ONLINE: "Should we stay or leave?"... - Chris Hum, 2012-04-16, 22:26
- NOW ONLINE: "Should we stay or leave?"... - AsOne, 2012-04-16, 23:30
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- NOW ONLINE: "Should we stay or leave?"... - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-17, 00:21
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- NOW ONLINE: "Should we stay or leave?"... - Sue, 2012-04-17, 03:23
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Direct communion with the heavenly Father - Ynot, 2012-04-17, 09:03
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Direct communion with the heavenly Father - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-17, 09:34
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Direct communion with the heavenly Father - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-17, 09:34
- What does Jesus Christ offer humanity? - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-17, 09:17
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- What does Jesus Christ offer humanity? - Liz, 2012-04-17, 09:56
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- What does Jesus Christ offer humanity? - Helen, 2012-04-17, 10:53
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- What does Jesus Christ offer humanity? - judith, 2012-04-17, 10:56
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Do we need a Papacy or a "central head office"? - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-17, 13:18
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Do we need a Papacy or a "central head office"? - Sue, 2012-04-17, 14:05
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Do we need a Papacy or a "central head office"? - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-17, 14:41
- Do we need a Papacy or a "central head office"? - Sue, 2012-04-17, 15:59
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Do we need a Papacy or a "central head office"? - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-17, 16:13
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Do we need a Papacy or a "central head office"? - judith, 2012-04-17, 18:48
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Do we need a Papacy or a "central head office"? - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-17, 19:50
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Do we need a Papacy or a "central head office"? - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-17, 19:50
- Do we need a Papacy or a "central head office"? - judith, 2012-04-17, 18:48
- Do we need a Papacy or a "central head office"? - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-17, 16:13
- Do we need a Papacy or a "central head office"? - Sue, 2012-04-17, 15:59
- Do we need a Papacy or a "central head office"? - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-17, 14:41
- Do we need a Papacy or a "central head office"? - AsOne, 2012-04-17, 22:45
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Do we need a Papacy or a "central head office"? - Sue, 2012-04-17, 14:05
- What does Jesus Christ offer humanity? - judith, 2012-04-17, 10:56
- What does Jesus Christ offer humanity? - Helen, 2012-04-17, 10:53
- What does Jesus Christ offer humanity? - Liz, 2012-04-17, 09:56
- Direct communion with the heavenly Father - Ynot, 2012-04-17, 09:03
- NOW ONLINE: "Should we stay or leave?"... - Sue, 2012-04-17, 03:23
- NOW ONLINE: "Should we stay or leave?"... - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-17, 00:21
- Unusual study asks former Catholics why they left church - PeterR, 2012-04-17, 11:34
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Unusual study asks former Catholics why they left church - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-17, 12:26
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- Unusual study asks former Catholics why they left church - desi, 2012-04-17, 12:57
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- "Should we stay or leave?" - Bill Dowsley, 2012-04-17, 14:39
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- "Should we stay or leave?" - Liz, 2012-04-17, 16:12
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- "Should we stay or leave?" - Liz, 2012-04-17, 16:12
- "Should we stay or leave?" - Bill Dowsley, 2012-04-17, 14:39
- Unusual study asks former Catholics why they left church - desi, 2012-04-17, 12:57
- Unusual study asks former Catholics why they left church - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-17, 12:26
- I have stayed put but - Englishwoman, 2012-04-17, 17:41
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- We should all pack up go home and send a note to Papa Bene... - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-18, 15:59
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- We should all pack up go home and send a note to Papa Bene... - Helen, 2012-04-18, 17:31
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- We should all pack up go home and send a note to Papa Bene... - desi, 2012-04-18, 17:45
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- We should all pack up go home and send a note to Papa Bene... - Mosley, 2012-04-18, 17:58
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- We should all pack up go home and send a note to Papa Bene... - Helen, 2012-04-18, 18:40
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- We should all pack up go home and send a note to Papa Bene... - Mosley, 2012-04-18, 18:42
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- We should all pack up go home and send a note to Papa Bene... - Helen, 2012-04-19, 01:03
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- We should all pack up go home and send a note to Papa Bene... - Helen, 2012-04-19, 01:03
- We should all pack up go home and send a note to Papa Bene... - Mosley, 2012-04-18, 18:42
- We should all pack up go home and send a note to Papa Bene... - Helen, 2012-04-18, 18:40
- We should all pack up go home and send a note to Papa Bene... - judith, 2012-04-18, 19:11
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- We should all pack up go home and send a note to Papa Bene... - desi, 2012-04-18, 19:50
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- We should all pack up go home and send a note to Papa Bene... - Mosley, 2012-04-18, 19:53
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- We should all pack up go home and send a note to Papa Bene... - Helen, 2012-04-19, 01:01
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- We should all pack up go home and send a note to Papa Bene... - J H Britt, 2012-04-21, 14:00
![Show preview […]](templates/Catholica1/images/ajax_preview.png)
- We should all pack up go home and send a note to Papa Bene... - J H Britt, 2012-04-21, 14:00
- We should all pack up go home and send a note to Papa Bene... - Mosley, 2012-04-18, 19:53
- We should all pack up go home and send a note to Papa Bene... - desi, 2012-04-18, 19:50
- We should all pack up go home and send a note to Papa Bene... - Mosley, 2012-04-18, 17:58
- We should all pack up go home and send a note to Papa Bene... - desi, 2012-04-18, 17:45
- We should all pack up go home and send a note to Papa Bene... - Helen, 2012-04-18, 17:31
- We should all pack up go home and send a note to Papa Bene... - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-18, 15:59
- I'm "stayin' put"... - Brian Coyne, 2012-04-16, 18:14
















