EDITOR'S ROUND-UP

Saturday, 14 July 2007

Isn't the essential lesson from both Peter and Paul
that we are all flawed human beings?

Dear friends,

Ian Elmer has a fascinating commentary today on St Paul. Reading it, and combining it with last week's commentary led me to ask the question I've headed today's email with: "Isn't the essential lesson from Peter and Paul that we are all flawed human beings?" Don't you think God might be trying to say something to us in having chosen two personalities like Peter and Paul to play such a leading role in the birth of Christianity?

Earlier this morning I was reading a little more of Leonard Swidler's book and I have to say I am as angry as hell at the way some of these people carried on in the wake of the Second Vatican Council trying to turn back the clock on all the reforms. (I'll have more to say about that in our forum.) These people who engage in those sorts of activities scarcely present themselves as flawed individuals with their inflated egos and self-belief that they know "truth" even better than God himself knows truth. The more I study the behaviours of a lot of the Pope's of the last 200 years the more disillusioned I become. These men have a hell of a lot to answer for in the way in which hundreds of millions of people have been driven out of the Church, and away from the true insights of Jesus Christ, by their certitude, their inflated egos and seeming belief that they could read the mind of God even better than God can read his own mind.

These two commentaries by Ian, to me point to an entirely different vision of what Catholicism and Christianity ought be all about. Our (Christian and Catholic) journey is supposed to be a very humble journey. I suggest it is also meant to be a very collaborative journey. We are all searching, yes, even the popes are searching, for these difficult-to-discern things called "truth". All of us are flawed individuals, yes, even the popes. We are all modelled on Peter and Paul in a sense. It is time we got back to behaving like a family — but not some paternalistic family where Big Daddy with his inflated ego and false humility thinks he knows best. Very often, and as history has now demonstrated with such devastating accuracy, very often these Big Daddy figures have not "got it right". Collectively, we as a Church need to get back to humbly acknowledging that we do not have "all the answers" — collectively we are all still searching for "all" the answers — and collectively we need to start acknowledging that a few of our leaders in the past have not got it right and have made terrible mistakes that need to be corrected before our Church can move forward again igniting humanity with the love, the peace and insight that Jesus Christ left us through these very flawed and very human people we find in the personalities of Peter, Paul and the many other women and men who first built the Church. <Read Ian's commentary>

Avatar

AND FOR OUR WEEKLY READERS HERE ARE OUR COMMENTARIES FROM THE PAST WEEK...

Peregrinus...

AvatarDivorce I: what did Jesus have to say on the subject? Over the next four Fridays we're re-publishing this series on divorce written by Peregrinus. The following excerpt from today's email helps put this in context: "Catholica is different to other internet initiatives. We are not some newspaper 'dressed up' and presented in a new format 'online'. We are not trying to build some massive subscription base as most internet initiatives are seeking to do. What we're trying to do is 'build a cyber community'. The personal experiences of many of us who came together to get this initiative off the ground is that very often the times when people are most receptive to thinking about spiritual issues is when they come across some time of crisis in their lives. Obviously times of divorce and relationship breakdown are one of the major times when people might be searching the internet seeking assistance. At Catholica we are not trying to build up some 'vast repository of official Church documents'. What we want to build up is a repository of basically 'ordinary, moderately intelligent people' talking in ordinary language about how they have handled these times of challenge in their lives. So, the principal reason why we are re-running Peregrinus' commentary on Divorce at this time is in an endeavour to try and ignite further discussion in our forum which, perhaps even many years down the track, some 'lost soul' might come across doing a 'Google search' and which provides them with 'just the answer I need'." <more>.

Daniel's Take...

AvatarWas Jesus married? Our lead commentary today is the fifth contribution by Daniel Gullotta, a young theology student at ACU National in Brisbane. Today Daniel examines the evidence on the recent controversies in the secular media pertaining to whether Jesus was married. This is a powerful essay from such a young writer. I think we might be witnessing here the emergence of a powerful communicator. Congratulations Daniel. I should also point out that Daniel is also responsible for choosing most of the graphics that accompany his essays. <more>

Peregrinus...

AvatarFurther info from the Census… Peregrinus has been doing some further research into the recently released Census figures. In his commentary today he shares a few further conclusions that might be drawn and also outlines some places where we need to be cautious in what we read into the figures. <more>

Andrew's Take...

AvatarThe End Game… In this essay, which he entitles "The End Game", Andrew Kania is exploring both the issue of consequence that flows from each action in our lives, and also the wider and more contentious issue that has caused plenty of invigorating discussion in our forum in the past – the final accountability of our actions, and life. <more>

Monday's Email...

AvatarWhat is required for evangelisation or re-evangelisaion? The announcement in the news today of the initiative by the Australian bishops to take the re-evangelisation effort a bit more seriously provides an opportunity to take the discussion a little deeper. Do you believe it is possible to re-vangelise the Church simply by "pumping up the volume" on the agenda that has been offered by the Church for the past forty or fifty years? <more>

Milly's Take...

AvatarOur behaviour does matter! Catholica Australia largely came into existence because of the difficulties in conducting conversations in other places on the internet. In this commentary, Milly, shares some thoughts on internet etiquette and responsibility… <more>

Best wishes for a great day wherever you happen to be ... in life, and in our world,

Brian Coyne
Editor and Publisher

Catholica Australia
34 Martin Place, LINDEN NSW 2778, Australia
tel: +612 4753 1226 | skype name: briancoyne | mobile: 0423 793 494
email: editor@catholica.com.au